2025’s Crosscurrents: Markets in tension
The current investment landscape presents a series of complex and often conflicting signals. While the S&P 500 has impressively recovered to within 4% of its February highs, a palpable sense of tension remains present. This environment is characterized by a tug-of-war between persistent economic risks and resilient asset prices, creating a challenging backdrop for investors. Restrictive interest rates and the administration’s shifting trade policies each pose tangible economic risks in the months ahead. As a result, long-term investors are forced to weather a period that we know will include potentially violent swings in stock and bond prices.
Now that the stock market has recovered from the sharp decline earlier this year, the best-case scenario for the remainder of the year may be one in which stocks simply go nowhere. In my view, the S&P 500 appears to be caught in a valuation dilemma. On the one hand, persistent economic strength could keep bond yields elevated, compressing the high valuations investors are currently paying for stocks. On the other hand, hawkish tariff talk threatens to dampen economic growth, which would, in turn, pressure corporate earnings growth. With the market no longer priced for a recession, the S&P 500 index may be confined to a wide range, potentially between the April lows near 4,800 and the February highs around 6,000.
Interest rate market
The volatility in the interest rate market is the biggest factor supporting this view. In particular, sharp swings in 10- and 30-year U.S. Treasury yields, which have been largely driven by uncertainty surrounding new tariff policies and the Fed’s decision to pause rate cuts, are key drivers to the market’s quandary. The Federal Reserve finds itself in a precarious position. The March FOMC meeting’s economic projections reflected this challenge, with forecasts for growth revised downward while inflation and unemployment were revised up. This has created a critical debate over the future path of monetary policy, leaving investors to determine the “real” sustainable level of interest rates.
This interest rate story is further complicated by a lack of alignment between monetary and fiscal policy. While the Fed contemplates the timing and magnitude of future rate cuts to achieve a neutral policy stance, the U.S. government is projected to run a budget deficit of nearly $2 trillion. Based on the contents of the proposed new tax bill, it appears that hopes for a deficit reduction have transformed into a deficit expansion. With the national debt now approaching $37 trillion, the sheer volume of government issuance could force long-term interest rates higher as investors—the so-called “bond vigilantes”—demand greater compensation for the risk. The administration wants the Fed to lower rates to stimulate economic activity. But, if the Fed attempts to lower short-term rates while the market pushes long-term rates higher, the yield curve will likely steepen.
Housing market
The real-world consequences of this monetary and fiscal tension are already visible in the U.S. housing market. Despite a recent report that showed a significant 30.6% Y/Y increase in the inventory of homes for sale—a post-pandemic high—buyer activity has fallen sharply. In fact, pending home sales fell 6.3% Y/Y, the largest monthly decline since 2022. The reason is clear: elevated mortgage rates, which are a direct consequence of the broader interest rate environment, are keeping potential buyers on the sidelines. According to the National Association of REALTORS®, a meaningful reduction in mortgage rates is essential to stimulate demand and absorb the growing supply.
Stock market
While home prices may be reaching a near-term peak in pricing, stock prices have risen by almost 20% since the April lows. The S&P 500 trades for 22x projected earnings for 2025 as compared to its historical average of 16-17x over the last 25 years. A higher PE multiple may be warranted given the increasing concentration of high-growth technology companies that constitute a record weighting within the index. There is no right answer to what the PE “should be” and there are many inputs that factor into reasonable valuation judgments such as interest rates, earnings growth rates, etc. However, the argument that the market is currently trading near historically high levels is not generally disputed.
Given this backdrop—a U.S. stock market with a potential ceiling, a volatile bond market, and a housing sector hampered by affordability—investors must remain vigilant and mindful of their risk tolerance. The forces that propelled the domestic bull market since late 2022 may be waning, suggesting that leadership may be shifting. Fortunately, opportunities to diversify and generate returns remain, even if the potential for big stock market gains like we have seen over the last couple of years have diminished.
In our view, the current environment calls for a defensive and diversified strategy, especially for investors that target capital preservation as a key objective. While corporations remain financially healthy and credit markets are not showing signs of significant stress at the moment, the headwinds are undeniable. We are focused on navigating this range-bound, volatile market by reducing over-concentration in high-priced speculative companies and emphasizing valuation discipline, while also exploring investments that have secular growth qualities and inflation protection attributes. For fixed income, the elevated yields on short-dated, high-quality bonds present the best opportunity in over two decades to lock in attractive returns. Navigating the road ahead will undoubtedly be a bumpy ride, but challenges also present opportunities.
Birthdays:
Actress and singer Idina Menzel turns 54 today, singer CeeLo Green turns 50, singer Wynonna Judd turns 61, and former Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer turns 50.
Christopher Gildea 610-260-2235